ARTICLE: The Importance of Choosing the Right Health Care Proxy Before a Health Crisis

The Importance of Choosing the Right Health Care Proxy Before a Health Crisis

When life feels steady, it’s easy to delay decisions about future medical care, but things can change in an instant. An accident, a sudden illness, or a new diagnosis can leave someone unable to explain what they want. In those moments, having a health care proxy makes all the difference.

A health care proxy (sometimes called a health care agent or medical power of attorney) is the person you legally appoint to make medical choices if you can’t. Putting this in place isn’t just paperwork, it’s a safeguard that gives you peace of mind and spares your family from being put on the spot.

Why It Matters

Without a proxy, doctors may turn to family members who don’t know your wishes—or who may not agree with each other. That can create confusion at the exact time when clear answers are needed. Choosing a proxy ahead of time means:

  • Your medical preferences are understood and honored.
  • Decisions are made by someone you trust.
  • Loved ones aren’t left arguing or guessing in a crisis.

Who Should You Choose?

The person you name as your health care proxy doesn’t always have to be the one closest to you. The right choice is someone who truly understands your values and priorities, can remain calm under pressure, and is willing to speak up for you even when it’s difficult. Just as important, they need to be both willing and able to take on the responsibility. For example, it may not be your spouse if you know they would feel overwhelmed by making medical decisions under stress. Instead, it could be a sibling, an adult child, or even a close friend who can confidently carry out your wishes. Once you’ve chosen someone, talk openly with them about your wishes—whether it’s the kind of treatments you’d want, how you define quality of life, or what matters most to you. The more they know, the better prepared they’ll be if the time ever comes for them to step in on your behalf.

Don’t Wait for a Crisis

Too often, families find themselves in a hospital hallway, forced to make decisions without guidance. Naming a health care proxy ahead of time gives clarity to doctors and comfort to the people who care about you most.

If you haven’t chosen a proxy yet—or if it’s been years since you reviewed your health care documents—now is the time. Call Roth Elder Law at 607-962-6162, or use our contact form, and we’ll follow up to set a time at your convenience.

Contact Us Today

We at Roth Elder Law, PLLC, believe in providing services in a way that clients can easily understand and meaningfully participate in designing and maintaining their estate plan for their loved ones, as well as be assured that their plan will be administered according to their wishes.